When industry leader Smith Optics revolutionized its helmet lineup with the Smith Payroll, it promised to redefine trail protection standards. After rigorous testing spanning over 100 hours across diverse terrains—from technical mountain biking trails to leisurely bike paths.
This comprehensive review dives deep into what makes this innovative piece of gear stand out in both traditional and e-bike communities.
A Game-Changing Overview
The Smith Payroll represents a significant leap forward in mountain bike helmet design, seamlessly combining Smith Optics’ renowned craftsmanship with cutting-edge safety innovations.
Positioned at a $200 retail price point, it sits firmly in the premium segment. However, the integration of revolutionary MIPS Evolve technology and advanced Koroyd protection systems justifies this investment.
What truly distinguishes this helmet is its coveted NTA-8776 certification for e-bike use, making it equally adept for both aggressive trail riding and modern Class 1 E-MTBs.
Standout Features
The groundbreaking Smith Vapor Fit System immediately establishes itself as an industry benchmark in helmet comfort technology. Unlike conventional adjustment mechanisms, it delivers precision fitting that maintains comfort even during marathon trail sessions.
The sophisticated integration of MIPS Evolve technology working in harmony with Koroyd honeycomb protection creates an unparalleled safety system without compromising essential ventilation.
The helmet’s enhanced back-of-head coverage and side-of-the-head coverage inspire unprecedented confidence during technical descents. During challenging hill climbs and intense cross-country riding sessions.
They strategically placed 19 vents and demonstrated exceptional efficiency in maintaining optimal airflow. The versatile 3-position visor system showcases remarkable adaptability, functioning flawlessly with both sunglasses and offering superior goggle compatibility—a thoughtful feature for varying trail conditions.
Understanding the Trade-offs: Considerations
The $200 retail price positions the Payroll in the premium tier of the mountain bike helmet market. While the advanced features justify the investment, it represents a significant commitment for casual riders.
Weighing in at 15 ounces, it’s noticeably more substantial than its sibling, the Smith Engage, though this additional weight directly correlates to enhanced protective features and extended coverage areas.
Comprehensive Specifications
| Feature | Detailed Specification |
| Construction Type | In-mold construction with Koroyd Honeycomb integration |
| Shell Material | Premium Polycarbonate shell |
| Interior Composition | EPS liner with premium anti-microbial foam pads |
| Safety Technology | Advanced MIPS Evolve system |
| Ventilation Design | 19 vents with strategic placement |
| Weight Classification | 15 ounces (Large size) |
| Safety Certifications | NTA-8776, EN1078, US CPSC |
| Visor System | 3-position adjustable design |
| Retail Price | $200 MSRP |
In-Depth Feature Analysis
Let’s dive into the standout features of the Smith Payroll helmet, beginning with its construction.
1: Advanced Construction Technology
The Smith Payroll showcases state-of-the-art In-Mold construction, featuring a meticulously engineered two-piece polycarbonate shell that’s seamlessly bonded to the high-density EPS liner.
This sophisticated integration creates an optimal balance between weight and structural integrity. The strategic implementation of Koroyd honeycomb technology in critical impact zones enhances protection without compromising the helmet’s overall weight distribution.
Smith Optics has precisely positioned the Koroyd sections to maximize protection in vulnerable areas while maintaining superior ventilation efficiency.
2 – Comprehensive Safety Features
The payroll’s safety credentials set new industry standards. The prestigious NTA-8776 certification confirms this helmet’s capability to handle impact testing at 28 mph—significantly exceeding the conventional 20 mph testing required for US CPSC and EN1078 certifications.
The advanced MIPS Evolve system represents the pinnacle of rotational impact protection, working seamlessly with the Koroyd honeycomb structure to effectively dissipate both linear and angular forces during potential impacts.
3 – Unmatched Comfort Engineering
The revolutionary Smith Vapor Fit System deserves particular recognition for its innovative approach to fit customization. The system employs an advanced strap configuration that eliminates pressure points even during extended riding sessions.
The premium anti-microbial foam pads are strategically positioned to complement the fit system, creating an exceptionally secure yet comfortable interface.
During extensive testing across various terrain types, from smooth bike paths to technical downhill riding sections, the helmet maintained consistent comfort without requiring mid-ride adjustments.
4 – Advanced Ventilation Design
The sophisticated ventilation system incorporates 19 vents designed through computational fluid dynamics to maintain optimal airflow patterns. During intensive hill climbs and demanding cross-country riding sessions, the helmet demonstrated superior heat management capabilities.
The Koroyd honeycomb structure, while providing crucial protection, contributes to ventilation through its innovative tubular design, allowing consistent airflow while maintaining structural integrity.
5 – Weight Distribution Analysis
At 15 ounces, the Payroll represents a calculated balance between protection and weight. The mass distribution demonstrates excellent engineering, with no noticeable imbalances. During extensive trail riding sessions.
The additional weight proved a worthwhile compromise for enhanced protection and coverage. Compared to the lighter Smith Engage, the Payroll offers substantially more protective features that justify its slightly higher weight classification.
Extensive Real-World Performance Testing
After conducting comprehensive testing across diverse riding conditions—from sun-drenched cross-country trails to technically demanding mountain biking descents—the Smith Payroll consistently demonstrated exceptional performance capabilities.
The helmet particularly excelled during e-bike sessions, where the increased velocity potential of Class 1 E-MTBs highlighted the significant value of its enhanced protection features.
Temperature Management Performance
During intense hill climbs in varying weather conditions, the helmet’s ventilation system proved remarkably efficient. The 19 vents worked in perfect harmony with the internal channeling system to maintain consistent airflow even during the most demanding ascents.
The Koroyd honeycomb structure, while providing crucial protection, never impeded airflow, maintaining comfortable temperature regulation during extended rides.
Impact Protection Assessment
The combination of MIPS Evolve technology and Koroyd protection creates a sophisticated safety system that exceeds traditional standards. The helmet-enhanced back-of-head coverage and side-of-the-head coverage provide comprehensive protection during technical descents.
The NTA-8776 certification ensures protection at speeds up to 28 mph, making it ideal for both traditional trail riding and e-bike adventures.
Comparative Analysis
When positioned against market competitors in the premium helmet segment, the Smith Payroll stands out in several key areas:
| Feature Category | Smith Payroll | Industry Standard |
| Safety Certification | NTA-8776, EN1078, US CPSC | Typically only EN1078 & US CPSC |
| Protection System | MIPS Evolve + Koroyd | Usually single protection system |
| Ventilation | 19 vents with Koroyd integration | 15-18 standard vents |
| Weight | 15 ounces | 13-14 ounces average |
| Coverage | Extended back-of-head coverage | Standard coverage |
| Price Point | $200 | $150-180 range |
Durability and Maintenance
The polycarbonate shell with in-mold construction demonstrates excellent durability during extended use. The anti-microbial foam pads maintain their shape and comfort even after prolonged riding sessions. The Smith Vapor Fit System shows no signs of degradation after extensive adjustments, suggesting excellent long-term durability.
Read also: Himiway Zebra D5 Fat Tire EBike: Test and Review
Recommendation – Buy or No Buy?
The Smith Payroll MIPS helmet represents a significant advancement in cycling protection technology. For riders who frequently transition between traditional trail riding and e-bike adventures, the NTA-8776 certification alone makes it a compelling investment.
The combination of advanced features, including MIPS Evolve technology, Koroyd protection, and the sophisticated Smith Vapor Fit System, creates a premium package that justifies its $200 retail price.
Ideal User Profiles
The helmet excels for:
- Dedicated mountain biking enthusiasts demanding premium protection
- E-bike riders, particularly those using Class 1 E-MTBs
- Trail riding specialists who frequently tackle technical terrain
- Cross-country riding enthusiasts who prioritize comprehensive safety features
- Riders who alternate between traditional bike paths and challenging downhill riding
Final Verdict
The Smith Payroll successfully bridges the gap between conventional mountain bike helmets and the evolving demands of modern cycling. Despite its premium pricing and slightly higher weight, it delivers exceptional value through its comprehensive protection package and versatility across different riding disciplines.
The integration of MIPS Evolve, Koroyd honeycomb, and the Smith Vapor Fit System creates a helmet that meets and exceeds current safety standards.
The Smith Payroll offers unparalleled protection, comfort, and versatility, whether you’re charging down technical trails, enjoying leisurely bike path rides, or exploring new territory on your e-bike.
It is a testament to Smith Optics’ commitment to advancing cycling safety and comfort, making it a worthy investment for serious cyclists who refuse protection.
Care and Maintenance Tips
To maximize the longevity of your Smith Payroll:
- Regularly inspect the polycarbonate shell for any signs of damage
- Clean the anti-microbial foam pads with mild soap and water
- Check the MIPS Evolve system for proper movement
- Ensure the Koroyd honeycomb sections remain properly secured
- Maintain the Smith Vapor Fit System by keeping it clean and debris-free
- Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight
This comprehensive protection system represents the future of cycling safety, making it an investment worth considering for any serious rider seeking the ultimate in head protection technology.
FAQ’s:
Is the Smith Payroll helmet worth $200?
Yes, if you’re a serious rider who values enhanced safety features. The NTA-8776 certification, MIPS Evolve, and Koroyd protection justify the premium price.
Can I use the Smith Payroll for e-bike riding?
Absolutely. It’s one of few helmets certified for e-bike use with NTA-8776 certification, tested for impacts at 28 mph.
How does the Smith Payroll compare to the Smith Engage?
The Payroll offers more protection features and e-bike certification but is slightly heavier (15 oz vs. 12 oz). It’s essentially a premium upgrade with enhanced safety features.
Is this helmet good for hot weather?
Yes. With 19 vents and an advanced channeling design, it provides excellent ventilation even during intense hill climbs.
What’s the difference between MIPS Evolve and regular MIPS?
MIPS Evolve is a newer, more integrated system that provides better ventilation and comfort while maintaining the same rotational impact protection.
How do I know if the helmet fits correctly?
The helmet should feel snug but not tight. The Smith Vapor Fit System should allow you to adjust without pressure points. The helmet shouldn’t move when you shake your head.
Is this helmet good for downhill riding?
No. While excellent for trail riding and e-biking, serious downhill riding requires a full-face helmet for additional protection.
How long does the Smith Payroll last?
With proper care, 3-5 years. However, replace immediately after any significant impact or if you notice damage to the polycarbonate shell or Koroyd.
Does it work well with glasses?
Yes. The helmet is designed to accommodate both sunglasses and goggles, with a 3-position visor for versatility.
Is the Payroll heavier than other trail helmets?
At 15 ounces, it’s slightly heavier than average, but the extra weight comes from additional protection features.
How do I clean the helmet?
Use mild soap and warm water. Don’t use harsh chemicals. The anti-microbial foam pads can be removed and hand-washed.
conclusion
The Smith Payroll MIPS Helmet delivers premium safety, comfort, and versatility. With advanced protection, ventilation, and e-bike certification, it’s a top choice for serious riders seeking reliable performance.
Primes Crafted is your go-to site for travel tips, destination guides, and helpful advice. Find everything you need to plan your next adventure and make your trips memorable.